Why Lead Time Matters More Than Unit Price in MRO Sourcing
Procurement scorecards reward unit price because unit price is easy to measure. Downtime is harder to attribute, so it stays invisible until a line stops and someone asks why the critical spare was not on the shelf.
Put a number on it. Take the contribution margin of the line per hour and multiply by the hours it stops waiting for a part. For a mid-size machining cell that number is often in the thousands of dollars per shift. Compare that with the difference between two suppliers quoting 12 dollars and 13 dollars for the same bearing.
Once downtime has a cost, the decision changes shape. A supplier holding stock in a regional warehouse can deliver in two days; a supplier shipping from a factory can deliver in five weeks at a lower unit price. For a consumable that you use steadily, the slow one wins. For a critical spare, the fast one wins by an enormous margin — and the honest answer is often that you should hold both: the cheap one for planned consumption, the fast one for the shelf.
This is the reasoning behind stocking programmes. We keep fast-moving MRO parts in regional warehouses for exactly this reason, and we quote lead time alongside price on every inquiry rather than after the order is placed. If a quoted lead time is longer than your maintenance window, the part is not actually available to you, whatever the price says.
The practical takeaway: ask every supplier for lead time in writing, ask what happens when it slips, and treat the difference between two lead times as a real cost line in the comparison rather than a footnote.