Stepper or Servo? A Practical Decision Framework
The default argument for servos is "they are more accurate". That is not quite right. A stepper with a good driver and a correctly sized load is extremely repeatable — it just cannot tell you when it has lost a step.
That is the real decision: does losing a step matter?
If the axis re-homes on every cycle, or the position is verified by a sensor, an open-loop stepper is fine and much cheaper. If the axis must stay in position across power cycles or after a jam, a servo (or a stepper with an encoder) is the safer choice.
Torque curves explain the rest. A stepper delivers high holding torque at standstill and its torque falls off with speed. A servo holds torque across a much wider speed range, which is why high-speed applications favour servos even when a stepper has enough nominal torque.
Heat is the second factor. A stepper draws full current at standstill to hold position, so it runs hot and wastes power. A servo draws almost nothing when holding. On a machine with many axes idling between cycles, that difference shows up on the electricity bill and in the cabinet temperature.
Noise and resonance are the third. Steppers have a mid-range resonance band that causes vibration and audible whine; microstepping and dampers reduce it but do not eliminate it. Servos are quiet across the range.
The pragmatic answer for most automation: use steppers where the axis is light, the speed is moderate, position is re-verified, and cost matters. Use servos where the axis is heavy, fast, must hold under load, or where a lost step means scrap. A 3-axis pick-and-place with re-homing on each cycle does not need servos. A CNC Z-axis does.